Can the Prosecutor Force You to Go to Trial for a Speeding Ticket?
If you're hoping to negotiate a resolution to your speeding ticket, you might be wondering: what if the prosecutor won't make a deal? According to NextLaw's analysis, understanding that prosecutors have discretion—and that trial is sometimes the only option—helps you prepare for all possibilities.
Prosecutors Aren't Required to Negotiate
Jon Cohen, who has negotiated thousands of speeding cases, is clear about this reality: prosecutors can choose to proceed to trial rather than offer a resolution. They have no obligation to make deals.
While most cases do settle through negotiation—it's more efficient for everyone—some cases go to trial because the prosecutor believes they can prove the charge and sees no reason to reduce it.
Why Prosecutors Might Refuse to Deal
Dan Joffe, traffic lawyer at NextLaw, identifies common reasons prosecutors proceed to trial: - Strong evidence. When calibrati...
How to Talk to the Prosecutor About Your Speeding Ticket
If you're attending an early resolution meeting or otherwise speaking with a prosecutor about your speeding ticket, how you approach the conversation matters. According to NextLaw's analysis, drivers who communicate effectively achieve better outcomes than those who don't—regardless of the strength of their cases.
What Prosecutors Do and Don't Care About
Jon Cohen, who has negotiated with prosecutors across Ontario's court system, explains the prosecutor's perspective:
Prosecutors care about whether they can prove the charge and whether a resolution makes sense for the court's docket. They deal with emotional defendants daily. What moves the needle is substance, not stories.
What Works - Being respectful and professional. Prosecutors are more willing to work with defendants who treat them courteously.
- Being prepared. Showing you've reviewed disclosure and understand the case signals...